How MER became so popular
Marketers got tired of trying to reconcile numbers that would never add up. MER offered an over-simplified solution (total spend / total revenue). If the ratio is healthy, keep going. This logic works only at a surface level.
Where MER breaks down
It hides what's happening with new vs. returning customers. A high MER might look great on the surface. However, if most of that revenue is coming from repeat customers who would have purchased anyway, your marketing isn't actually as efficient as the number suggests. You could be spending $50,000 a month on acquisition and mostly just taking credit for organic repeat purchases.
It can be misleading during growth phases. If you increase spend to test a new channel, your MER will almost certainly drop in the short term. That doesn't mean the new channel isn't working. It might just need time to ramp. MER alone can't tell you whether a dip is a problem or an expected cost of expansion.
What to use alongside MER
MER is worth tracking. It just shouldn't be the only thing you track. The e-commerce brands that measure marketing well use MER as their top-level health check and then layer in other data to understand what's driving the number.
How to bring it all together
ThoughtMetric shows multi-touch attribution data broken down by channel, campaign, ad set, and ad. It tracks new vs. returning customer revenue, includes post-purchase surveys, and connects directly to your store so the revenue numbers are accurate. When your MER moves in either direction, you can drill into the attribution data to understand what changed and where to adjust.